Music · Study 02 of 3
Ptolemy: Hearing and Ratio
A theory of tuning must answer both to numerical relations and to the sound it is meant to describe.
In this study
- Combine intervals by multiplying their ratios.
- Distinguish an exact numerical comparison from a listening judgement.
First bearings
Ptolemy’s Harmonics opens with the criteria used in harmonic investigation and the relation between hearing and reason. Its early chapters discuss consonance and the monochord as a means of testing ratios. Jon Solomon’s translation and commentary provides a modern route into the text. The linked edition record identifies that work; it is not a promise of free full-text access. Reading references ↓
An interval is not an arithmetic gap
Successive intervals multiply their ratios. A fifth followed by a fourth gives (3/2) × (4/3) = 2, an octave. Dividing one ratio by another finds the interval between them. An experimental comparison must also state the instrument, tuning, and listening conditions. A numerical identity can be proved exactly; a claim about perception requires observations and cannot be supplied by arithmetic alone.
At the desk · an original exercise
Finding the interval between fourth and fifth
Starting from the same reference, the just fifth is 3/2 and the just fourth is 4/3. Their quotient is (3/2) ÷ (4/3) = 9/8. This is a whole-tone ratio in this tuning framework.
From 240 Hz, the fourth is 320 Hz and the fifth 360 Hz. Comparing 360 with 320 again gives 9:8. Subtracting gives 40 Hz, which is a frequency difference, not a scale-independent interval ratio.
Try it yourself
Two successive 9:8 tones have what combined ratio? Is it equal to 5:4? Calculate both fractions before deciding whether the labels “two tones” and “major third” identify one exact tuning.
Compare your reasoning
Two 9:8 steps give 81:64, or 1.265625. The ratio 5:4 is 1.25, so they are not equal. Their quotient is 81:80. This calculation shows a tuning difference; it does not by itself establish how a particular listener will describe or prefer it.
A boundary to keep in view. This exercise uses a few simple ratios, not Ptolemy’s complete system of genera and tunings. Never treat one tuning model as the only historically possible meaning of an interval name.
Source reading
- Ptolemy, Harmonics: Translation and Commentary
Jon Solomon, Brill (2000), edition/publisher record. Begin with Book I.1–2 and I.8; full access may require a library. The worked calculations on this page are original.
AstroToolz introductory study notes. Explanations and exercises are modern teaching material, not quotations or critical editions of the historical texts. External readings are identified by language, edition, or source type above.